Benedictine Spread – Kentucky Derby Finger Foods

Benedictine Spread - a traditional Kentucky Derby Finger Food.  Perfect for a bridal shower, baby shower or wedding shower.

One of the delicious traditional finger foods of Kentucky Derby parties are sandwiches made with this delicious Benedictine spread. The combination of cream cheese and cucumbers makes a great spread for afternoon teas, garden parties, and Derby Party buffets. It’s full of fresh flavor and easy to make.

Benedictine Spread on Bread – Served on our Floral Paper Plates

You’ll want to make this delicious spread a day ahead to allow the flavors to meld, but don’t assemble the sandwiches until the day of the party to avoid soggy bread. (A very light coat of butter on the bread before the Benedictine spread will help keep your sandwiches from getting soggy.)

Cut your bread into horseshoe shapes to stay on theme for a Derby Party. These delicious little finger foods will disappear fast at a bridal shower or baby shower.

Grated Cucumbers for Benedictine Spread

This Benedictine spread is also perfect for spring weddings, engagement parties, and summer barbecues. Everyone loves the fresh cucumber flavor, and the recipe can easily be doubled to prepare for a larger party or wedding.

Kentucky Derby Benedictine Spread

A light and delicious spread for finger foods and sandwiches as you celebrate the Running of the Roses!
Prep Time20 mins
Course: Snack
Cuisine: American
Keyword: appetizers, Benedictine spread, canapes, cucumbers, finger foods, Kentucky Derby, Tea party
Servings: 16


  • 1 large cucumber
  • 1 8 oz package of cream cheese softened
  • 1 TBSP mayonaise
  • 2 TBSP grated onions very finely grated
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon black pepper


  • Peel the cucumber. On a large box grater, grate on the larger side, the peeled cucumber, and place into a small bowl.
    Grated Cucumbers for Cucumber Spread
  • Grate on the small side of the box grater a peeled onion, enough to make the 2 Tablespoons.
  • Place the cream cheese, mayonaise, black pepper, and salt into a stand mixer bowl, fitted with the paddles attachment.
  • Beat on medium until the cream cheese mixer is light and no clumps remain.
  • Add the onions and cucumber to the bowl with the cream cheese and beat on low for 1 minutes.
  • Remove the bowl from the mixer and hand stir until well combined. Don't overmix.

Place the mixture into a small bowl, and cover. Best if refrigerated overnight before use.

    If you’re looking for more great Kentucky Derby party ideas, see our 5 must try ideas post and shop the entire Kentucky Derby party supplies collection.

    Pin this recipe for later.

    Creamy cucumber party spread made for baby showers bridal showers and finger sandwiches.

    Subscribe to the EnFete Newsletter

    Subscribe to receive our monthly free printable, hear about exclusive offers, private sales, new products and party ideas

    Share this post:

    Share on facebook
    Share on twitter
    Share on linkedin
    Share on pinterest
    Share on email
    Share on print
    On-trend and fun party decorations boutique party supplies by EnFete
    Carey Greene Owner of EnFete boutique party supplies for all your occasions - read all about her

    I’ve always loved to throw a good party. But I always knew, it’s not just a party. Whether it’s a birthday, bridal shower, anniversary or baby shower, a special event is just that—truly special.

    Hi, I’m Carey! The Owner and Designer behind EnFete. I was bit by the party planning bug at just six-years-old and haven’t looked back ever since. 

    Read More →

    gold line 81px-04
    Shop Derby Bridal
    EnFete is a boutique party supplies store - for your elegant baby shower, bridal shower, wedding engagement party - and more

    Subscribe for a free monthly printable

    Scroll to Top